I've been playing NHL since '94, on all game systems (mostly on the PC). I finally got around to buying GameCube and bought this game -- and was a bit disappointed. Don't get me wrong, its a playable, fun exciting hockey game that continues the EA tradition, but it has some bad aspects (I play on medium with all official NHL rules):
1. The AI is not up to par. Players will skate over the puck with out picking it up, which is really annoying. Also, players take a long time to get out of the zone (which can result in frustrating offsides). I also think the defensive AI is somewhat poor -- it is hard to get the puck from the computer in your zone and sometimes it feels like they're running circles around you.
2. The game options are lacking. There are less stats and options than there are on the PC version. For instance, you can't save games while you're in the middle of playing (you have to quit or leave the game on pause until you come back). The stats and player profiles are also limited.
3. The functionality can be annoying. You have to save your franchises after every game, which requires saying yes to about 4 dialogue boxes. Why can't it just auto-save it or at least minimize the effort required to save it?