| Overly harsh punishment |
A sleazy showcase of sadism, slapstick and sentimentality, this version of The Punisher is only marginally better than forgettable Dolph Lundgren version. Good performances from Rebecca Romijin, Ben Foster and John Travolta, and a cameo by Roy Scheider, don't quite make up for the way the film turns slaughter into a joke by veering drunkenly from the subfusc to the ridiculous.
Reviews I've read suggest that the directors' cut manages to explain away most of the plot holes, but I feel no urge at all to see it: I'm not sure what comics readers did to deserve this, but whatever it was, we've been punished enough already. |
2 Rating
|
| Extended cut of this film is better |
The punisher is one my all time favourite comic book heros and this film is favourite comic book movie so far. The extended cut of this film contains 17 mins of extra footage that was cut from this film, the extra footage put back in this film gives it a more story driven film inccluding in scene of who gave Frank Castle up to Howard Saint. If you already have this film, but don't have the extended cut it's worth checking out. |
4 Rating
|