| Script assumes you are unintelligent and unknowing |
The use of present-tense verbs to describe events from the past is now commonplace in our post-literate age, especially by historians when talking down to lay people. This script does that, and worse. Consider this excerpt: "In the 1950s, travel to the Moon is about to become possible because of the rocket. Long used as a weapon, the rocket is the only engine that can be used in a vacuum." That's not true, and it's the kind of falsehood that sometimes happens when adults over-simplify their subject for children.
Or this one: "But when future generations look back, they may be surprised to learn why men first went to the Moon, because the ancient dream of exploration had almost nothing to do with what was called Project Apollo." The script reveals that the true motive was to beat the Russians. How typical of Nova to be so condescending to its audience as to assume we have no understanding of the political context. And the truth is that Apollo had a great deal to do with the dream of exploration.
Or this one: "In 1968 men first left the Earth for the Moon. Millions of people watched their journey on television, but scarcely a handful knew how it really began." Oh, so fewer than six people knew how Apollo 8 really began. Nonsense.
Or this one: "For an astronaut to survive there [in space], he'll need the protection of a spacecraft, or capsule. Even a small capsule will need a huge rocket to put it in space." Sounds like they are talking to small children.
Or this one: "Lost between the pioneering flights of Mercury and the lunar triumph of Apollo was the program that found the answers. It was called Gemini. Nearly forgotten today, Gemini was the essential step to the Moon." Lost and forgotten by whom? I sure didn't lose it, and I'll never forget it. I wish Nova would stop making things up and stick to the truth. In what sense was Gemini more essential than the other steps?
Nova has it that few people know the true motive behind Apollo, or the true beginnings of Apollo 8, or even the existence of the Gemini phase. But Nova knows. Nova always has the answers, and we are children sitting at their feet, grateful for any bits of knowledge they deem to hand down.
The DVD includes the commercials that air at the start of every episode of Nova. I would say that's an indicator of the low esteem Nova has for its audience. |
1 Rating
|
| Great for the new enthusiast |
This documentary gave me exactly what I was looking for. Born 15 years after the first Moon landing, the whole space race was old news when I learned about it in school. I knew the major events, but the details were lost. I wanted to know more about the young space program and the lunar missions, but I didn't want to sit through the hours and hours that some of the other documentaries offer.
Nova has condensed all the basic facts to create an informative summary. I gained a new perspective regarding the huge and seemingly impossible achievements. I don't think anyone could do a better job with so many events in a 2 hour DVD.
For me, the interest peaked during the coverage of Apollo 8 and the launch of Apollo 11, but the later missions don't disappoint. I really liked the addition of the 3D animations, which help to illustrate aspects of the flights not captured on film. As for the "bad" music mentioned in previous reviews, I hardly noticed. It's not the best quality, but it's far from obtrusive.
If you've already seen everything about the missions, this DVD may not be for you. But if you're like me and wish to gain some perspective regarding the era, this is a great place to start. |
5 Rating
|
